White man

Whiteman

The risk of hypocrisy here is enormous. But I promised 500 words, so I’m going to do my best. Really, if I had time and money and sense, I’d find someone with the right perspective to write this for me.

White man.

So this is Brian trying to express sympathy and solidarity for the genocide of Native people led by European colonists. I think the intention is pretty solid.

Of course, he’s Brian May, so he’s doing it through the medium of hard rock, some Queen’s hardest, actually.

I think it’s the first time we’ve seen Queen being actively political (aside from the implied personal politics of loving whilst gay and not out) . I’ve tried to shoe horn anticapitalism into a few of the earlier songs, but this is clearly written with a very specific intent. Taking culpability and trying to process and amplify that white people destroyed nations and lives to make space for itself.

There’s a problem though. And it’s the same problem I end up with if I go much further with this.

He does it all by taking the role of the Native.

The narrator of the song challenges, curses and holds the white man accountable.

Now. Freddie’s relationship with colonialism is complicated. But May is a quintessential white man.

At best, the whole thing is an acre of cringe with a solid guitar crunch underneath it. In reality though, it’s another invasion. Another space colonised. May’s attempt to give voice to a struggle ends up supplanting that voice with his own. He escapes blame by speaking from the oppressed position. It feels like allyship at its worst.

Which of course, is why I don’t want to judge the song, and talk about the narrative in any more detail. It doesn’t matter if it seems right or wrong to my ear (and the use of a clear racist epithet at the start of one verse speaks against it). Really, it needs to be torn apart by the people whose voice May is trying to speak for.

And that’s not me.

There’s a chance, of course, that I’m miles off. That the whole piece was constructed in consultation with the surviving Native people (the song makes no effort that I can see to specify a particular nation or culture). That May did the legwork, talked to people, wrote collaboratively, and is giving voice to a specific person.

But, well, there’s no sign of it. And to do this right, you have to attribute and specify, really. Freddie’s own colonised and immigrant history probably isn’t enough to wash off the sense of privilege.

Sure, there’s probably some excuses about the time. I’m sure this felt like sticking a neck out and doing the right thing. But it doesn’t really make a difference, and it stops me from being able to discuss this in any other light. I can’t gloss over, and I can’t go deeper without repeating the problem.

So this is what you get. A link to the song, and a set of problems I can spot, even from my position of ignorance and privilege.

One of my worries about Queen, and a lot of music I’m passionate about, is that it essentially becomes a form of escapism, ignoring the realities of the world for the sake of emotional release. So on some level, I want to praise Queen for taking up a political cause and making a statement. And it is clearly trying to be on the right side. It’s not as if I’ve ever criticised them for a lack of nuance before.

But no. It’s not enough to make the statement, if you don’t figure out how to do it right

 

Sorry if I’m being just as bad. I’d really love to hear the views of anyone Brian is trying to speak for here. I’ll happily remove anything I’ve to make space for that perspective. And I’m sorry I haven’t sought it out already.

 

 

Queen: An Exploded Diagram is me having big and little thoughts about every Queen song in chronological order. If you want to support me, making it more financially viable and easier to explain to people at parties, please back my patreon.

Illustration by Emma.

One thought on “White man

  1. My heritage is Seneca and I have often wondered about the origins of this song. I actually don’t see a problem with this song. I like it & have since its release. Brain May may be simply sympathizing with the plight of America’s native peoples in the most eloquent and artistic way he possibly could. I would love to know his actual thoughts on the matter, however, I don’t see him wasting his time talking with me. The sins of the father should not be held to the son, even if you call May the “quintessential white man,” he is not responsible for what was done and is being done to the native peoples of the Americas. Maybe he read ‘Creek Mary’s Blood’ that has fiery speeches by Tecumseh, but are not based in fact, but fiction. Maybe Brian May got fired up about the never ending injustices Native Americans have and will face and he need to express his outrage.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s